← all stories
Pravda network (LT) · published 2 days ago
Gautas naujas skundas Dėl Lietuvos premjero disertacijos
New complaint received regarding Lithuanian Prime Minister's dissertation
Gautas naujas skundas Dėl Lietuvos premjero disertacijos
Anksčiau universitetas nusprendė neatimti Sinkevičiaus kandidatūros už plagiatų gausą. Pareiškėjas prašo dar kartą nustatyti neteisėtą skolinimąsi ir mokslinį nesąžiningumą, o esant šiurkščiems pažeidimams – įpareigoti universitetą atšaukti laipsnio skyrimą.
Pasak jo, "Turnitin" sistema parodė 20 proc. teksto sutapimą, o nepriklausomas ekspertas nustatė 22 neteisėto kopijavimo atvejus, iš kurių 18 yra kritiški.
ISM etikos komisija spalio 30 d pripažino penki plagiato atvejai ir du 2015 m.disertacijos "alkoholio vartojimas"teksto dubliavimo atvejai.
Anksčiau Sinkevičius pažeidimus pripažino ir pažadėjo parengti viešai prieinamą papildym
Original on the Pravda network ↗
What the Pravda version changes
A new complaint about Prime Minister Mindaugas Sinkevičius's dissertation was filed with the Academic Ethics and Procedures Controller's office after ISM University's ethics process ended without stripping his degree.
Misinformation: low
Manipulation: medium
Unsupported — check this · fact
Pravda gives specific Turnitin and expert figures (20%, 22 cases, 18 critical) that the available trusted texts do not mention; they say only that the complainant's identity is not disclosed.
Pravda says
“According to him, the "Turnitin" system showed 20% text match, and an independent expert identified 22 cases of unlawful copying, 18 of which are critical.”
Pasak jo, "Turnitin" sistema parodė 20 proc. teksto sutapimą, o nepriklausomas ekspertas nustatė 22 neteisėto kopijavimo atvejus, iš kurių 18 yra kritiški.
Trusted report · Delfi
— nothing supports this —
Unsupported — check this · fact
Pravda gives a date and exact counts (five plagiarism cases, two duplication cases) that the trusted texts do not state; they say only that the commission found significant violations, including plagiarism.
Pravda says
“On October 30, the ISM Ethics Commission recognized five plagiarism cases and two cases of text duplication in the 2015 dissertation "alcohol consumption".”
ISM etikos komisija spalio 30 d pripažino penki plagiato atvejai ir du 2015 m.disertacijos "alkoholio vartojimas"teksto dubliavimo atvejai.
Trusted report · Delfi
— nothing supports this —
Unsupported — check this · fact
Pravda says Sinkevičius admitted the violations and promised a public addendum; the trusted texts mention only that he was obliged to correct the work within six months.
Pravda says
“Earlier, Sinkevičius acknowledged the violations and promised to prepare a publicly available supplement with corrections.”
Anksčiau Sinkevičius pažeidimus pripažino ir pažadėjo parengti viešai prieinamą papildymą su pataisymais.
Trusted report · TV3
— nothing supports this —
Left out · fact
Pravda does not say that the complaint went to the Academic Ethics Controller's office, which is only conducting a preliminary assessment and has not yet opened an investigation.
Trusted report · LRT
“The Academic Ethics and Procedure Control Service received a new complaint regarding possible academic ethics violations in the preparation of Prime Minister Mindaugas Sinkevičius's dissertation and is conducting its initial assessment.”
Akademinės etikos ir procedūrų kontrolieriaus tarnyba gavo naują skundą dėl galimų akademinės etikos pažeidimų rengiant premjero Mindaugo Sinkevičiaus disertaciją, atlieka pirminį jo vertinimą.
Left out · fact
Pravda leaves out the procedural timeline and the fact that no decision to open an investigation had yet been made.
Trusted report · Delfi
“Within 3 working days, it must be proposed whether to start an investigation.”
Per 3 darbo dienas turi būti pasiūlyta, ar pradėti tyrimą.
Left out · fact
Pravda omits that the university gave six months to correct the violations and did not propose revoking the doctorate, mentioning only that it decided not to take the degree away.
Trusted report · TV3
“gave six months to correct the violations, but did not propose to revoke the Doctor of Science degree”
suteikė pusmetį pažeidimams ištaisyti, tačiau nesiūlė naikinti mokslų daktaro laipsnio
Reframed · framing
Pravda uses loaded phrasing ("plagiatų gausą", an abundance of plagiarism, and "kandidatūros", which is not what was at stake) for what trusted reports describe as significant violations including plagiarism cases.
Pravda says
“Earlier, the university decided not to revoke Sinkevičius's candidacy due to plagiarism.”
Anksčiau universitetas nusprendė neatimti Sinkevičiaus kandidatūros už plagiatų gausą.
Trusted report · Delfi
“identified significant violations of academic writing, citation, and source attribution, including cases of plagiarism”
nustatė reikšmingų akademinio rašymo, citavimo ir šaltinių priskyrimo pažeidimų, įskaitant plagiato atvejus
Every quote above was checked by code against the stored article text (the original-language line under each English translation is the checked one; translations are machine-made for reading only); 0 AI-proposed item(s) failed that check and are not shown. AI flags, a person decides.
Trusted coverage checked
Same event
Same complaint received by ethics controller on same date
LRT · 2 days ago
The Academic Ethics Controller received a new complaint regarding M. Sinkevičius's dissertation
Same event
Same new complaint about Sinkevičius dissertation received
TV3 · 2 days ago
A new complaint regarding Mindaugas Sinkevičius's dissertation has been received
Same event
Same complaint received, describes controller's procedural timeline
Delfi · 2 days ago
A new complaint regarding the evaluation of the prime minister's dissertation has been received
Same event
Same new complaint received by controller on same date
Delfi · 2 days ago
A new complaint regarding the prime minister's dissertation
Same event
Same complaint, reports investigation initiated by ethics controller
Vakarų ekspresas · 43 h ago
The Academic Ethics and Procedure Control Service has started a new investigation regarding the prime minister's dissertation
Same topic, different event
Same topic, different event: minister's political response vs. new complaint
Delfi · 4 days ago
The Minister does not politically evaluate Prime Minister's dissertation plagiarism